Dette essayet oppnådde karakter A i emnet Hemispheric Asymmetry.
Tilbakemelding:
The essay provides a generous interpretation of the question “Do hormones affect hemispheric asymmetry?”, but it certainly discusses aspects of both hemispheric differences and hormones. And the selected topic is, of course, interesting.
The introduction provides a very good background and leads well to the selected research question. Both articles fit well to the chosen approach and are
Vis mer Dette essayet oppnådde karakter A i emnet Hemispheric Asymmetry.
Tilbakemelding:
The essay provides a generous interpretation of the question “Do hormones affect hemispheric asymmetry?”, but it certainly discusses aspects of both hemispheric differences and hormones. And the selected topic is, of course, interesting.
The introduction provides a very good background and leads well to the selected research question. Both articles fit well to the chosen approach and are summarised in an understandable way. The discussion of the findings was very good and balanced, although it is usually difficult to make a coherent story from fMRI findings. The discussion could maybe have been a bit more critical of the methods. For example, do asymmetric significant activations indeed show hemispheric differences? Also references to hemispheric differences in emotional processing could have been discussed. As a side note: The right-sided activation in the first study in relation to romantic love is well in line with the idea that the right side “does” the emotions, but somewhat contradicts the alternative idea that the right hemisphere is negative emotions/encourage withdrawal from a situation.
What struck me was the substantial number of references that were integrated. As these mostly pre-date the two discussed articles, I assume that their inclusion was mostly inspired by the citation in the two articles. In future essays try to demonstrate more indepedence from the orginal material.
The overall layout of the paper is good, and the APA standard are followed.
Taken together, an excellent essay, which was accordingly awarded with an “A” (14. of 15 points according to grading instruction)
Vis mindre
Du må være innlogget og ha kjøpt dette dokument for å kunne gi en omtale.